Where to Go in Cat Island — Bahamas: Regions, Cities & Routes

Old Bight, Columbus Town & Fernandez Bay

Base · 4–5 nights

The best all-round first-visit base: long empty sand, swimmable water and the island’s strongest mix of beach houses, small inns and useful access to the centre. Stay here if you want Cat Island to feel restful rather than logistically demanding.

first-timerscouplesbeach lovers

Mount Alvernia & the Hermitage

Short stop · 1 day

Cat Island’s essential short hike: a steep walk to Father Jerome’s tiny stone Hermitage and the broadest view of the island. It is a worthwhile stop, not a full-day outing—pair it with New Bight or a beach afternoon.

first-timerswalkersphotographers

The Bight & New Bight

This is the practical middle of the island, with the more useful airport, fuel and groceries, local food around the fish fry, and the road to Mount Alvernia. Choose it for convenience rather than for a polished beach-town atmosphere.

short-stay visitorsself-driversfirst-timers

Port Howe & Greenwood Beach

Base · 3–6 nights

The southeast is for committing to the beach: Greenwood’s huge pink-sand shoreline, dive operations and kite-friendly conditions can easily occupy several days. It is remote enough that staying put is the smart move.

diverskiteboardersbeach lovers

Arthur’s Town

Base · 3–4 nights

The cultural anchor of north Cat Island, Arthur’s Town feels lived-in rather than visitor-built and is the place to connect with Rake ’n’ Scrape and Sidney Poitier associations. It makes more sense as a north-island base than as a quick stop from the south.

culture seekersfestival-goersreturn visitors

Orange Creek & Port Royal

Short stop · 1 day

The island gets rougher and more interesting here: inland tracks, caves, blue-hole country and a landscape that rewards local advice over Google Maps. Come for an exploratory day, not a tightly scheduled attraction circuit.

independent driverscave explorersgeology enthusiasts

Smith’s Bay, Tea Bay & Man O’ War Bluff

Short stop · 1 day

A raw central-east coast for side-road wandering, unplanned beach stops and near-total solitude. This is Cat Island at its least structured, best approached from an Old Bight or New Bight base.

road trippersrepeat visitorsfamilies renting houses

French Bay & Hawk’s Nest

Short stop · 1 day

The southern resort-and-marina option, with more organized diving, fishing and watersports than most of the island. It suits travelers who want activity support without giving up Cat Island’s quiet.

anglersdiversmultigenerational groups

Dumfries, Bennett’s Harbour & Hallover

Short stop · 1 day

This central-northern belt is for the slow-drive crowd: farms, small settlements, inland roads and food traditions rather than marquee sights. It works best as part of a north-to-centre transfer or a guided rural day out.

food-curious travelersslow travelersindependent drivers

Bain Town & Mermaid Hole

A worthwhile inland detour for Great Lake, better known as Mermaid Hole, and the folklore around Cat Island’s blue-hole landscape. Treat it as a locally checked natural feature, not a managed swimming attraction.

geology enthusiastscurious first-timersindependent drivers

Sample routes

Classic first visit

7 nights

Old Bight, Columbus Town & Fernandez Bay (4 nights) → Port Howe & Greenwood Beach (3 nights)

The sensible first Cat Island trip: start with the island’s easiest beach base, use it for Mount Alvernia, New Bight and one properly long north-island day, then finish on Greenwood’s remote sand. Do not try to squeeze French Bay or another hotel move into this week.

Plan this route

North-island culture and beach downtime

8 nights

Arthur’s Town (3 nights) → Orange Creek & Port Royal (1 day trip from Arthur’s Town) → Old Bight, Columbus Town & Fernandez Bay (5 nights)

For travelers who want Cat Island’s lived-in north—not just its beaches. Base in Arthur’s Town, explore Orange Creek with local advice, then move south once and give Old Bight enough time for empty-beach days, Mount Alvernia and the central-east coast. This is the right shape for a Rake ’n’ Scrape Festival trip.

Plan this route

Greenwood dive and beach week

6 nights

Port Howe & Greenwood Beach (6 nights) → Mount Alvernia & the Hermitage (1 full-day excursion from Port Howe & Greenwood Beach)

A specialist itinerary for oceanic-whitetip diving, kiteboarding or doing very little on a very long beach. Keep the whole stay at Greenwood and leave weather buffers around dive days; Mount Alvernia is the one inland outing worth the drive. It is deliberately not a comprehensive island tour.

Plan this route

The full Cat Island at a humane pace

14 nights

Arthur’s Town (4 nights) → Orange Creek & Port Royal (1 day trip from Arthur’s Town) → Dumfries, Bennett’s Harbour & Hallover (Transfer-day exploration en route south) → Old Bight, Columbus Town & Fernandez Bay (5 nights) → Mount Alvernia & the Hermitage (Half-day excursion from Old Bight, Columbus Town & Fernandez Bay) → Smith’s Bay, Tea Bay & Man O’ War Bluff (1 day trip from Old Bight, Columbus Town & Fernandez Bay) → Port Howe & Greenwood Beach (5 nights) → French Bay & Hawk’s Nest (1 day trip from Port Howe & Greenwood Beach) → Bain Town & Mermaid Hole (Short locally checked detour during the central-to-south transfer)

This is the version that respects Cat Island’s distances and slow logistics: a real north base, a genuinely useful central beach base, then a proper southeast stay. The minor stops are excursions, not excuses to repack; you still have enough unplanned beach time for the island to work its particular magic.

Plan this route